72100 Overseas Highway, Craig Cay, FL

$10,500,000

Previous Next

67,000

Square feet

About 72100 Overseas Highway

Welcome to one of the rarest offerings in the Florida Keys. This extraordinary 1.62-acre bayfront property on Craig Key, just south of Islamorada, is more than land; it is a canvas for creating a legacy estate in paradise.From the moment you arrive, the sweeping open-water views set the stage for a lifestyle defined by privacy, luxury, and timeless beauty. Imagine waking up to the glimmer of the Gulf, entertaining at sunset with endless horizons as your backdrop, and stepping onto your boat for instant access to world-renowned fishing and boating waters.This remarkable parcel boasts over 300 feet of waterfront, protected deep-water access, and a private boat basin with 106 feet of concrete dockage. Unlike any other property in the Keys, it can accommodate yachts up to 100 feet with over 6 feet of depth, offering rare boating capabilities that set it apart. Few properties combine this level of seclusion with such exceptional waterfront amenities.The acreage allows for complete design freedom. Whether you envision a modern architectural masterpiece, a tropical island retreat, or a multi-generational family compound, the possibilities are as limitless as the views. Plans for a spectacular estate are available upon request, offering a glimpse into what this property can become.Craig Key itself is a quiet, exclusive enclave offering ultimate tranquility, while the restaurants, resorts, and vibrant culture of Islamorada are only minutes away. It is a location that offers both seclusion and connection--the perfect balance for those who demand the best of both worlds.This is not simply a property. It is an opportunity to create a landmark estate in the Florida Keys: an investment in beauty, legacy, and lifestyle that will endure for generations.

Features of 72100 Overseas Highway

MLS® # 616671
Price $10,500,000
Square Footage 67,000
Type Vacant Land
Status Active

Community Information

Address 72100 Overseas Highway
Area 22 - Lower Matecumbe
Subdivision Craig Cay Island (72)
City Craig Cay
County Monroe
State FL
Zip Code 33036

Amenities

View Open Water View, Bay View
Is Waterfront Yes
Waterfront Bay Front, Open Water, Gulf Front

Interior

Has Basement No

Exterior

Lot Description 1 Less Than 2 Acres

Additional Information

Date Listed October 1st, 2025
Days on Market 13
Zoning SR - Sub Urban Residential District
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No

Listing Details

AgentDerek Rodberg
OfficeCoastal Realty of the Florida Keys

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?